Key Takeaways from Crisis in the C-Suite: Who Leads When Things Go Sideways

Key Takeaways from Crisis in the C-Suite: Who Leads When Things Go Sideways

On October 8, Corporate Directors Forum hosted Crisis in the C-Suite: Who Leads When Things Go Sideways? at Morrison Foerster in San Diego. Directors, executives, and guests discussed common boardroom crises such as cyber breaches, CEO allegations, unexplained stock swings, and short seller pressure. The panel addressed key questions: Who leads during a crisis? When should the board intervene? How can directors and management share information to strengthen the company’s response?

Tommy Felix, Partner at Morrison Foerster, moderated the discussion. Panelists were Dil Erkin, Co-Founder and Managing Partner of Halo Partners, and K.C. White, Chief Legal Officer and Head of People at a.k.a. Brands (NYSE: AKA).Their expertise in investment, legal, people leadership, and federal enforcement provided boardroom, C-suite, and regulatory perspectives.

Below are the key highlights from the discussion.

In a Breach, Know Which Decisions Can Be Undone

The initial hours after a cyber breach focus on legal obligations, including state breach notification laws and the GDPR’s 72-hour rule. Immediate priorities are engaging cyber counsel and forensics. The panel advised distinguishing between reversible and irreversible decisions. Notifying the insurer, retaining counsel, and filing a claim can be done quickly and reversed if needed. Public statements and assigning blame cannot be undone. Incorrectly blaming a vendor can permanently damage trust.

Customers are the exception to a cautious approach. The panel recommended informing affected customers promptly, even if not all details are known. Delaying notification for 24 to 72 hours while data remains exposed causes more harm than early disclosure.

Management Owns the Answers. The Board Owns the Questions.

Directors typically intervene when management is in conflict, misses key steps, or crosses a materiality threshold. In these situations, a 48-hour delay from management is unacceptable. The board requires real-time updates on scope, revenue impact, and customer exposure.

The CEO should not make high-stakes, irreversible decisions alone, such as paying a ransomware demand. Board approval distributes accountability and offers protection. The panel summarized the division of roles: management owns the answers, and the board owns the questions.

When the Crisis Is the CEO

Allegations against a chief executive alter decision-making dynamics. The company, not the CEO, is the legal client. The general counsel should step back from decision-making and report to an independent director. For interim leadership, the board should first consider untainted members of the management team before turning to its own members.

Placing a CEO on leave does not imply legal wrongdoing. It safeguards the integrity of the investigation, especially when the CEO’s relationships could compromise the review. When considering whether to support a controversial CEO, the panel favored making a change. Visible misconduct often signals deeper cultural issues, and companies typically emerge stronger after taking action.

The panel also addressed a subtler issue: a founder-CEO who continues to micromanage as the company surpasses $200 million in revenue. In these cases, the board should use KPI performance, clear delegation structures, and robust succession planning.

No Surprises: How Information Should Flow

Management rarely loses the board’s confidence because of the crisis itself. Confidence erodes when management works in isolation and informs the board only after reaching a solution. The panel endorsed “No surprises” as the guiding principle.

Directors prefer facts over conclusions, a clear outline of unknowns, and recommendations with alternatives. Excessive raw information is also problematic. The panel advised omitting filler, emotional language, and superlatives. Board overreactions often result from insufficient information or too many conclusions from management.

Internally, “no comment” is never appropriate, as employees will fill the silence with rumors. It is better to communicate what the company knows, what actions it is taking, and when the next update will occur. Explaining why certain information cannot yet be shared builds more trust than remaining silent.

Focus on the Business, Not the Stock Price

The panel described a real case in which a thinly traded stock rose from $3 to $50 in a single day, with no known cause, and corrected within 36 hours. The board debated whether to issue a press release or stay silent, and the price corrected before any announcement. The recommended approach is to identify the cause first. If the increase is due to meme-driven trading, clearly inform employees who hold equity that nothing material is happening.

When short sellers apply sustained pressure, the board should press management on whether the short thesis is valid rather than react to the share price. Reactive press releases and 8-Ks create a disclosure practice that is difficult to reverse. The panel offered a cautionary example of a CEO who complained about the stock price on an earnings call, after which the stock fell further. Senior leaders should clear public statements, including on social media, with legal, because Reg FD applies. Companies raising capital should not release any public statements without legal sign-off. 

 Prepare the Process, Not the Script

A good crisis plan is more effective than preparing for specific crises. The plan should identify the team, decision-makers, and process. The panel noted that boards often under-invest in crisis preparation and cited AI governance as a topic that seemed irrelevant a year ago but is now critical.

After a crisis, the board should evaluate management on the timeliness and effectiveness of the response. Outcomes take longer to assess, usually 12 to 24 months, and are reflected in customer retention, renewal rates, talent retention, and Glassdoor trends. Boards should also assess their own actions, as directors often realize in hindsight that they delayed difficult leadership decisions.

Why These Conversations Matter

We thank Dil Erkin, K.C. White, and Tommy Felix for guiding the discussion, and Morrison Foerster for hosting us in San Diego. Crises rarely occur at convenient times, and the best directors have considered difficult questions in advance with trusted peers. This is the purpose of CDF programs.

Interested in learning more about CDF membership and upcoming programs? View Member Events or learn more about becoming a member or strategic partner today.